The following are some thoughts after seeing the show:
I have just watched the Secret Life of 4 Year Olds which is based on observation over two weekends, each six months apart, observing children. The men with PhDs, who said they had never been able to listen to children like that before (this group of children wore microphones), were the only ones who commented on behaviour while the female teachers were not shown expressing any opinion even though they had a lot more contact with children this age. This felt one-sided.
The children were fascinating but I won’t comment on their behaviour.
Channel 4 describes the show as follows:
This documentary follows 10 four-year-olds as they meet at nursery, exploring how children make and break friendships, share, stand up for themselves, and find their place in a new social group.
Dr Paul Howard -Jones is from the University of Bristol and one of two educational neuroscientists who observe the children from behind the scenes by observing the action on monitors. The show cuts away at regular intervals to the two male scientists reacting to the children while watching them and listening on headphones.
Jones said :”Even though I wasn’t interacting with the children, I found myself becoming incredibly involved, emotionally, in the narratives that were developing for each individual child.”
The other scientist was Dr Sam Wass from the Cognition and Brain Science Unit at Cambridge University.
The two women who do interact with the children are “highly trained teachers” and their profiles are not posted on the website and their opinions are not sought.
The questions I have about this show
1. How much of children’s behaviour is copied from their carers?
2. How can the scientists draw conclusions from the children’s actions without seeing how their carers behave?
3. Do the teachers agree with all the conclusions?
4. what do the teachers have to add about individual children and group behaviour based on their experience and education?
5. What do they think about the limitations and benefits of filming children over such short periods of time?Tweet